Skip to content
digital_developer
IndustryDigital Fairness ActEuropean Commissionvirtual currencypay-to-win

EU draft Digital Fairness Act would require real-money prices for in-game currency

The European Commission's draft Digital Fairness Act would affect game monetisation well beyond loot boxes, according to a GamesIndustry.biz analysis. Feedback from the games industry is open until January 14th.

Digital Developer Desk, 8h ago, 3 min read

Image: GamesIndustry.biz

The European Commission published its draft Digital Fairness Act last week. A GamesIndustry.biz analysis says the draft would reach well beyond loot boxes and pay-to-win, with significant impact on game design. It also says some voices in the industry warn that European developers would be hit particularly hard.

Article 14 covers paid-for virtual currencies, including secondary in-game currencies that are only indirectly acquired. Where items can be bought with them, companies would have to show the matching monetary value in real currency. The draft also requires that value to be shown when the currency is spent, not only when it is bought. The analysis raises open questions: how to calculate it when the currency can also be earned through gameplay, and how to display euro prices inside core gameplay without breaking immersion. It also says that treating virtual currency as having real-world value could have consequences for player bans, game shutdowns and possibly taxation. It notes that the DFA does not say any of this explicitly.

The draft prohibits pay-to-win for children. It defines pay-to-progress and pay-to-win mechanisms as purchases that are necessary, or presented as necessary, for progress or success. The analysis argues this definition may be too narrow, since an item that helps but is not strictly required might fall outside it. It adds that the pay-to-progress wording could cover anything from unlocking a full game after a free trial to paid DLC.

The analysis also criticises the text as over-engineered and hard to apply. The Commission itself identifies six overlapping EU legal acts in Article 4, and where they conflict, the other law governs. The author says that is a burden for indies without large legal teams, particularly given the 6% turnover fine ceiling.

On the European angle, the analysis notes that Supercell's CEO and industry associations have warned European publishers could be hit especially hard. The DFA also applies to non-European publishers doing business in Europe. The author argues that enforcement tends to fall on domestic companies more often, and that smaller companies tend to focus on their home market first.

The Commission has invited feedback, and people in the games industry have until January 14th to submit it. The analysis says changes may follow and that it will be some time before the DFA is adopted.

Sources

Get the daily brief

The five stories that matter, every weekday morning. Free.